Blindness (2008) by Fernando Meirelles

00018781The film adaptation of José Saramago’s Blindness, remains faithful to the novel and proves as disturbing in its realism, and critique of modern civilization. We as spectators, do not only witness the inhabitants’ infection with physical blindness, but with moral as well, as the facade of civilization, gradually disintegrates into savagery. The film provides profound insights as to the nature of humanity, and the true source of power, invisibility, which seems to be that, which allows one to be above all human laws and social contracts.

The theme of invisibility, clearly runs through the movie, and is even featured in the story the protagonist reads to a young boy. At the end of the day, it seems that, one is moral only when seen. People lose their sense of right, as soon as they lose their sense of sight, and consequently, their ability to perceive whether they are themselves seen. Discipline, thus can no longer apply, as all panopticons suddenly disappear, and the world reverts to a state of primitiveness, where the strong reign, and shamelessly exploit the weak. Blindness could easily work as an allegory, for the lack of insight that characterizes modern societies, in which people cannot see themselves, and the consequences of their actions, and in extend regulate themselves. This is consistent with the way, blind people gathered at the medical facility, can no longer see their own feces, and dirt, to pick it up.

The facility, which becomes a concentration camp for the infected, soon resembles a hell of impunity, where values, no longer mean anything. Time is nullified, as within a visual void it is of no importance, and the torment extends into eternity. The protagonist, and only woman retaining her sight, sheds bitter tears, at the grim realization that she has forgotten to wind up her watch, and has now sunk, along with the blind, into the oblivion of timelessness, where linearity and coherence become obsolete. Her husband comes to cheat on her, in front of her eyes, and she, to our astonishment, does not blame him, or even protest, acknowledging the peculiarity of circumstances. Survival becomes the ultimate moving force, and people are willing to sell the last crumbs of their dignity, in order to save what is left of themselves, from the ruthless opportunists who exploit them.

Whatmore, as in war, women become commodities, and men, feel emasculated, in their inability to react and protect them. It is deeply unsettling how men, seem to be considered more about their “property” being taken away from them, by other men, rather than the ordeal the women are obliged to endure, the invasion of their own bodies. When the doctor is asked whether he consents in sending the women, and his own wife, to the neighbouring ward, to exchange sex for food, he responds with, “I can’t say that it doesn’t hurt my male ego”, as if that is all that there is at stake here. This indifference towards the well-being of the women, and the risk they all took for the sake of their ward members, is highlighted through the murder of one of them, which occurs during the “exchange”.

In this new world, there is no comfort to be found, not even outside the facility. The soldiers who are supposed to guard their less fortunate counterparts, actually make fun of them and exploit their weakness to entertain themselves. People laugh at one another, instead of showing compassion. All they do is exploit circumstances to their advantage, without qualms, or false pretences, people normally use, to get what they want. Under the veil of invisibility, people are essentially selfish and cruel, solely siding with their own “tribes”.

The blindness gradually extends to the outside world, and along with it, the blindness to the needs of one’s neighbour. Upon the ruins of civilization, all pretences dissolve, and it is each to his own. Even our protagonist, during the supermarket scene, frantically attempts to flee from the masses that crave her food, and starve as much as her. She feels extremely possessive of the food supplies, and even the basement itself, where she found them. She only cares for her group of people, her newly formed “tribe”, having reverted, along with everything else, to a sort of primitiveness, in which, one tribe competes with all others, for resources essential to survival.

Adding, some things, never change, they just find new ways to manifest themselves. It is noteworthy how people, even in blindness project racial prejudices onto voices. A man characteristically states, “I won’t let a nigger tell me what to do”, in his ignorance of the race of the man terrorizing them, and that of his friend, who is actually black. In the same light, we get an unobstructed glimpse into the function of religion, that is, to comfort people. Through the artful addition of the church scene, we witness the way religion adapts to satisfy that need, by accumulating new aspects of culture within it. The priest announces to his sheeple, referring to a disciple, that “God made him blind”, in order to test his faith. He, as a representative of the church, attempted to give meaning to the ordeal people were going through, when there was none.

To conclude, people always look for justification, and rationalization, in what they are going through, as a way to comfort themselves, in an arbitrary universe with no right answers, ruled by randomness. It is a source of hope that allows humanity to fight for survival, and always opt for better days. Blindness, ultimately illustrates, how our whole social existence is based on mass delusions. It puts them under examination, under circumstances, different than our own, allowing us thus, to evaluate them more objectively, and understand how blind our own civilization has made us.

Enemy (2013) by Denis Villeneuve

tikz3wmkhdgrep88q8vxBased on José Saramago’s novel The Double, comes Denis Villeneuve’s psychologically unsettling film Enemy, centring on professor Adam Bell and his relations with his doppelgänger, actor, Anthony Claire. The movie opens with a statement, “chaos is order not yet deciphered”, informing us that there is a lot to untangle, and put in a coherent form, in what we are about to see. Most takes, feature a predominant yellow, suggestive of an omniscient decay – a looming sickness. The plot unfolds as Adam first encounters his exact look-alike, Anthony, through a movie suggested by his colleague, entitled Where There’s a Will There’s a Way, in which the actor had played a minor part. The title of the movie comes to be eerily poignant, as we increasingly realise that Adam’s double, is in fact, his way out of his cloistered and limiting reality, and ultimately a means of exploring his darkest desires.

While their initial encounters seem to suggest that they are a pair of completely different people, leading separate courses in life, and brought together by some absurd twist of fate, there are constant and subtle hints, which indicate that this is not the case. At a point we are lead to question, whether the two men are twins, but as it turns out they are identical copies of one another, and even sport the same scars onto their bodies. Adam’s mother dispels the last of our doubts in the dinner scene, where she is confronted on the matter, and categorically denies any possibility of her having had another son. She also mentions of Adam’s childhood dream of being an actor. Furthermore, it seems that the men’s controversial relationship to blueberries, bears the strongest evidence of them all, as Anthony likes them, and Adam not, and yet his mother informs us otherwise. As he himself states, in one of his classes, “history repeats itself, first it’s tragedy, then it’s a farce”, and such is the nature of his doubling.

It is also interesting to observe, the correlation of femininity with spiders, and the underlying viciousness it attributes to human relations of sexuality. Spiders are poignantly chosen to demonstrate these elements, as for many species, it is often the case, that the females devour the males during, or after, copulation. Perhaps, this is the initial source of pressure which caused Adam to split. It is very likely that he views relations with women, as threats to his autonomy and self, eventually crushing under the weight of responsibility, and commitment. He seems to find relief from this looming threat, by attending strip clubs, where a woman symbolically squashes a spider under her heel. It is noteworthy, that Adam’s relationship to his girlfriend is restricted to sex, an indication perhaps, that he is actually married to Anthony’s wife, and her, is in fact, his illicit mistress, through which he seeks escape from his duties. When one has an extramarital affair, it is commonly referred to, as having a double life. Moreover, both women are blonde, and share similar physical characteristics, indicating a consistency in taste, hinting once again, towards the two men, being two different facets of one.

enemy-picThrough the life of Anthony, it is likely, that Adam finds an opportunity to retreat into a fantasy world, full of novelty and exciting possibilities. By the end however, it becomes unclear, which of the two personas is the “real”, or the “original” one, if there was such thing in the first place. The two of them gradually develop a deep sense of antagonism, possibly as to which one will come to be the valid representation in the outside world, and thus, dominate “reality”. The double, ultimately appears as a manifestation of an internal conflict of interests, as seen by the way one persona sabotages the attempts of the other. It is that shadow-self, which represents all that is other, and with which, one is in a constant dialogue with. One’s identity, after all, is dependant on that which one is not, to validate it as what it is. At the end of the day, perhaps the worst enemy is one’s own self.

That Obscure Object of Desire (1977) by Luis Buñuel

that_obscure_object_of_desireAs the title suggests, Mathieu perceives Conchita as an elusive object of desire, one that can be bought if the stakes are high enough. His view is at best dehumanizing, as he debases her into a commodity and fails to account for her complexity as a human being. He completely fails to engage with her internal world and lacks even the most basic understanding of her psyche. To our astonishment, he seems to be utterly unaware of her swift changes into a whole new other person, her different facets and their implications. His sole concern is to possesses her as an object and reduce her into his trophy-mistress, to which it always seems that she is about to give in and yet, at the last moment, to our surprise, she resists and rejects him entirely, until further notice of course.

As it is suggested, the sole reason behind the maddening intensity with which he pursues her, lies in the fact that he can never fully possess her. He is enamoured with the idea of Conchita, the fiction he has constructed around the alleged eighteenth year old virgin, rather than the essence of her. She narrates a beautiful story and he keeps falling for it. It is unknown however, onto which length the deception goes, as the lines between their fictional romance and reality blur. One can assume that Conchita is neither eighteen, as she looks much older, in both of her impersonations and neither a virgin, as suggested by her overall promiscuity. Eventually, she becomes a canvas for his own projections to take shape upon it, as through her constant challenging of him,    she becomes his work in progress, one which he constructs through a game of guessing. Within his own assumptions, he paints her as he likes and is thus willing to give anything to have that painting. She becomes a fictitious ideal for him and winning her affections drives him to the brink of obsession, unsettles him to the core of his being.

800fullAlthough it seems no more than the pursuit of a childish whim, a vicious caprice, he cannot help but succumb to it, deeply intrigued by that which he cannot have and hopelessly entangled in the emotional sadomasochism it promises. It is a romance that reinvigorates his existence and gives him a newfound sense of purpose. He wants no other woman, but her, which allows him to experience an extraordinary adventure of pursue, a ride in an emotional rollercoaster without end. Despite his respectful position and mature age, she manages to channel within him, a sexual longing that had been long buried and a child-like immaturity that characterises his blind expedition into the unknowable space of their relationship. The very scene, in which he pours a bucket of water onto her, is strong evidence of this alteration in his mindset and an indication that he has surpassed his own limits of reason in his uttermost passion for her.

It seems that Conchita exploits his urge to possess her and plays along with his notions of ownership, under the mask of their impending relationship, as at times she does present herself as a commodity. She understands the rules of the game and she’s playing to win, as she realizes that when a commodity is rarely attainable it costs much more and thus by refusing to be bought, she raises her value towards her advantage. In that way, she’s like no other for Mathieu; she is of infinite value to him, in her refusal to settle for any value at all. When his friend offers him the chance to meet other young and attractive women, he instantly declines, professing that it is not merely an issue of sexual desire and that it is the idea of her that she pursues and the intensity the two of them share, even if he fails to understand her miserably. He is so utterly consumed by the thought of her that he does not even bother to look at other women. It becomes apparent in the cold, professional and indifferent way he faces his new chambermaid, who is also attractive and about the same age as Conchita. One cannot help but think that the two women could have easily switched places, had Conchita not had the insight to beat him at his own game and make herself irreplaceable.

6580_5On the other hand, Conchita openly mocks Mathieu and his views, in exhibiting her independence and cruelly teasing him throughout the film. She accepts all of his gifts and yet, she is not bought by them and asserts that she does not owe him a thing. He does not give her things because he loves her; everything is done in hope to win her through them. She realizes his motives and even exploits them, but as it always turns out, her responses prove his every attempt futile. When he bribes her mother she replies with a note “I would have given myself to you but you tried to buy me.” Even when it seems that the two will finally reconcile in Seville, with Conchita about to comply, she surprises both Mathieu and the audiences with her biggest act of rebellion. She asks for a house and when he provides it, she locks him outside and shares intimacy with another man right in front of him, stating: “My guitar is mine, I’ll play it for whom I please.” Through this setting, she affirms that her body is not an object to be possessed by Mathieu and that her sexuality is entirely her own and she will do as she pleases with it.

Her portrayal by two actresses, rather than one, only strengthens the complexity of her character, as she is practically two different people. Whenever Mathieu comes close into possessing one of them, she quickly shifts into the other. Her two contrasting facets serve as to construct Mathieu’s ideal whole, an all-inclusive femininity that bedazzles him, despite its ambiguity. In this manner, she is both virginal and sensual, only serving as to increase his frustration at her elusiveness and desire her all the more. The warm, lascivious and passionate Conchita, portrayed by actress Angela Molina, serves as to create the sexual tension, while the more reserved, stiff and lady-like Conchita, as portrayed by Carole Bouquet, keeps him hooked with her innocence and the promise of her potential deflowering. It is unclear which of the two versions of her is in fact the most realistic and whether such thing exists in the first place. One can interpret the doubling of Conchita as evidence of her duplicity, but it is arguable that all people can be seen as multifaceted as her and that it would be very one-dimensional to perceive them otherwise. Perhaps no one is solely one person, given the underlying deception behind social norms and its integral part in our everyday lives, as one is called to assimilate a variety of roles in everyday encounters that shape our reality.

Buñuel, once again includes random touches of absurdity. Mathieu is seen at two instances carrying a sack, for no apparent reason, other than the fact that it felt right to the director. There are many things that we do in our lives which are utterly incomprehensible, unnecessary and arbitrary and yet we indulge in them, simply because we can. These are essentially subconscious desires that manifest as the absurd, which comes to disrupt our cohesive notions of reality. The very romance amongst the two is such an instance, as it is characterized by the same absurdity and arbitrariness. Conchita herself is presented as thus, a walking contradiction in the form of the ever-incomprehensible other, perhaps unknowable even to herself, as her two facets become the double of each other.

The film ends in irresolution and conflict, both reflected and disrupted through the explosion that concludes the story. Mathieu and Conchita are once again arguing, showing how the war between the two is still alive, probably to no end, as it is an essential part of their fatal attraction. As they are lost within their own little private sphere of strife and romance, oblivious to the outside world and the public concerns, the political sets in upon them and destroys them, a reminder of the absurdity of life itself, if one considers how short and frail it is. We get subtle tastes of violence throughout the film, which serve as to bring to our awareness the various terrorist acts and remind us of their looming threat. Overall, the political, seems to be characterized with the same irrational tones and impulses of their tempestuous relationship, illustrating how humans are prone to exhibiting such behaviours, under the mask of civilization and reason, leading to impending destruction. Even the name of the most predominant terrorist organization suggests it, as a title such as “Revolutionary Army of the Baby Jesus”, only portrays the resistance as utterly ridiculous. The explosion, rather than a conventional happy ending, reflects the impossibility of a resolution, as one can never know the other. The two characters are trapped within their own sex game, until the explosion that possibly claimed their lives, deems it trivial. Mathieu’s object of desire will always remain obscure, as long as it is perceived as an object.

tumblr_mb2of0vCSZ1rzdm29o1_500

Water (2005) by Deepa Mehta

review_water_520

Water is set in 1938, while India is still a British colony and deals with the issue of widowhood and the destructive impact it has had on the lives of so many women. Widows are forced upon one of two choices, one is to perish alongside their husband and be consumed by the fires that will engulf his dead body, or to live in an ashram, dead to the world and deprived of any rights or control over their own existence. Women are coerced to comply through the terror inspired by religion, a cultural aspect deeply ingrained within law itself and are threatened to be reborn into a womb of a jackal, if they fail to do what is widely considered right. As inscribed in The Laws of Manu, widows should live a self-restrained and chaste life, in order to go to heaven. However, the widows, as we soon realize, far from lead a “pure” existence, as their leader Madhumati forces them onto prostitution and lives off their earnings. She is absolutely ruthless when it comes to finding a means to her end and she unhesitatingly uses a child, sends Chuyia to be raped, in order to replace the money she would otherwise get from Kalyani, who has had the same fate as Chuyia as a child. With the help of Shakuntala, Chuyia eventually manages to escape her culture of hypocrisy and is promised a better future somewhere else. At the end, it seems that Narayana has failed to save Kalyani, but will save Chuyia instead, who was doomed to the same fate as her.

Once their husband dies, widows are deemed useless, as a woman’s sole purpose was considered to be a companion to a man, a complementary presence to his own. Custom demands that widows are dumped in the temples that serve as human wastelands, while as Narayana informs us by the end of the film, it is none but a practical excuse for the family to get rid of an unwanted mouth to feed and be spared from spending money any further on a person that supposedly has none else to offer. Chuyia, in her partial ignorance of religion and innocence, offers the widows a refreshing surge of truth, as to the nature of their confinement to the temple. The widows, in contrast to her, have come to internalize these notions that deprive them of having any word or whatsoever, upon their own lives. When Chuyia asks them where the men-widowers go, the women are appalled and horrified and reply that God should protect men from such a fate, as cruel as their own. They submit to a horrendous lifetime, because a religion, constructed by men in power, says so. They are taught to respect the men who fashioned their shackles, through the means of religious texts, which they have learned and accepted as the absolute truth.

The internalized oppression is evident all throughout the exchange between Narayana and Kalyani, in which she asserts that good traditions should not die out, while he counters her opinion, by asking who gets to decide what is good anyway. She answers him that he is the one that gets to decide what is good, given his position and status. Her response illuminates the whole invisible sphere of politics that are at play behind every custom and how deeply embedded patriarchal oppression is, within religion itself. It is after all, none but a mask the ruling class wears, to manipulate the masses and keep them fixed and uncomplaining into their given stations. The figure of the patriarch in power is represented by the character of Narayana’s father, who has slept with Kalyani, in the belief that whichever woman he sleeps with is blessed, interpreting the religious books as he saw fit. The film ends with a message, delivered through Ghandi’s words. He reverses the traditional values and states that god is not truth, but truth is god. He prompts people to stop seeking the truth in “god” and religion and start seeking truth on its own account instead.

water-deepa-mehta_h_partb

Earth (1998) by Deepa Mehta

KiteShantaICMEarth offers us a horrifying glimpse into the tragic events that occurred during the partition of India in 1974. It is ultimately a coming of age story, both for the little Parsee girl, who narrates the story from the perspective of her adult self and for the nation of India itself. The events of the partition seem to deprive both Lenny and the people of India of their innocence, as they undergo through a process of disillusionment and come to cross the fine line between civilization and savagery, with the promise of a utopia turned dystopia. The film centres on a circle of friends, of diverse religious backgrounds, which come together, mostly in an attempt to court the beautiful Shanta, the Hindu nanny of Lenny. The film initially comes out as vibrant and rich in its stunning imagery and vivid colour, denoting thus, a pleasant, harmonious and long-lived coexistence amongst the common-folk of vastly different faiths. It is flooded by images of red, as seen on roses, balloons or garments that attribute intensity and cheerfulness, to everyday images and simple encounters. As the story progresses however, red becomes increasingly attached to acts of cruelty and becomes eerily reminiscent of rivers of blood and the on-going brutal violence.

The British apply the usual strategy of divide and conquer, to divert the masses from the real problem that is them and make them distrust one another as to weaken and eventually split the nation. It is apparent that in the beginning, as reflected by individuals in Shanta’s company, people’s good intentions proved stronger than the colonist’s propaganda, although gradually they all began to succumb to mob-mentality and fanaticism, as fear and collective panic set in. Even Dil Navaz, who is initially portrayed as a reasonable and peaceful presence, turns into a heartless monster by the end of the movie. He too, upon encountering the sexualized crimes the Hindu committed against his Muslim family, had been infected with hate, which he ended up directing on his own friends. Just as it had happened to many before him, grief muddled his reason and caused him to shift, from an understanding and open-minded individual, into a desensitized murderer. People found themselves caught in the midst of a vicious circle of recurring violence, endlessly reproduced and countered with even more bloodshed and destruction. The film speaks of how hate breeds hate and how a flicker of a fire can set a whole nation ablaze. Peace is none but a frail thing, as we see people manipulated into shedding the blood of their former “brothers”, to satisfy the interests of those in power. The leaders are none but disembodied voices from radios and speakers, presented as completely detached and outside the sphere of impending danger, expressing empty words from a position of safety.

We are also made aware of instances in which individuals use the overall chaos and strife, as an excuse for committing atrocities of their own account, in an attempt to relinquish their repressed anger, or as Dil Navaz put it, the caged lion inside of them raging to be set free. Dil Navaz’s murder of Hassan and betrayal of Shanta, out of sheer jealousy, are such instances in which the personal manifests under the guise of the political. Furthermore, the overtly sexualized crimes may have been indications of suppressed sexuality, but more evidently of the degraded role of women and the oppression they faced within Indian society. Adding, the people of India, on their entirety, had stored an excess of repressed anger, due to being under the British for too long, who constantly treated them as inferior. Therefore, for many, the national splitting was the perfect opportunity to lash out onto other people and let their “inner lions” and primitive instincts roam free. Within the small company of people we are introduced to, we notice their interpersonal relationships gradually collapsing, as friends turn on one another, to mirror the effect the partition has had on the larger scale. The possibility of coexistence is diminished, as friendships among people of diverse religions become scarce or even impossible.

Encountering violence reproduced violence and difference was translated into sheer hate and fear. This is reflected through Lenny, who upon witnessing the splitting a man in the course of public protest, goes home and pulls apart her own doll. She and a friend of hers split it, in relentlessness determination, but once the deed is done, Lenny is overwhelmed with remorse. The doll however, cannot go back to the way it was, similar to the way India will never be the same and the man will not come back to life, as all has already been split. It is almost as if all instances serve as metaphors for the partition itself, the nation torn asunder and the endless re-enactment of the circles of violence that produced. The plate Lenny breaks at the very beginning of the movie, is another of those metaphors, as the broken pieces can never be mended into one, ever again, just like the people who lived together in peace for so many years, are simply too broken to do it anymore.

We also take a glimpse at the world of the Parsees, who boast the ability to blend like sugar in milk and still retain their sweetness. Their power lies in their invisibility that allows them to survive all of the violent political events, at the price of a silence, reminiscent to moral death. Lenny, on the day of her birthday, encounters another child about her age, who tells her of the misfortunes his family had undergone and of his mother’s death. Her only reaction is to egotistically announce that is her birthday and ask the mourning child whether he would like some cake, to which he replies: “What is cake?” This response puts the Parsees to shame, as it illustrates how limited their perception was and how confined they were into their own sphere of safety. Adult Lenny, having remained uninvolved with the tragic events and safe within the sphere of her family’s protection, narrates the story. She is the one that lives to tell the tale, indicative perhaps that the stories are written from those who experience them from the outside, rather than those who live within them and are consumed by them.

Once Upon a Time in Anatolia (2011) by Nuri Bilge Ceylan

maxresdefault

The whole movie is characterized by an eerie atmosphere of futility, a pensive mood and an overall melancholy that casts its shadow over life depicted in it. It is taken in long-shots that allow cinematic time to flow uninterrupted and thus depict life as realistically as possible. Ceylan, in his attempt to paint a realistic portrayal of life in rural Turkey, includes scenes of triviality and the meaningless exchanges that characterize most of our daily interactions. He does not try to alter life and therefore chooses not to relieve the audiences of the plague of existential boredom, implied in every encounter with the self and otherness. The endless scenes of uncertain searching for the body, serve as to reproduce it and act as reflective means for the audience, in the search of meaning and coherence, both in the film and in life itself.

Ceylan, as we find out from interviews, insisted in attributing to the film as realistic qualities as possible, casting actors whose personalities resembled closely those of the characters they were to impersonate. The characters themselves were fashioned after the ones he frequently encountered during his childhood years in the villages of rural Turkey, the aura of which he tried to recreate and bring to life, as closely as possible. Through them, he hopes to understand human nature. The film is created as a mirror of life, in which nobody knows what is actually going on and motives are as opaque for the characters themselves, as for the audiences. We are presented with no answers or resolutions for anyone, as even the director himself, admits in an interview, that the whole project was an attempt of his own to understand life. There is no comfort for anyone, only loneliness and silence, as each one carries their own internal worlds, with thoughts words prove inadequate to articulate, in circumstances that confine the complexity of expression. The stillness and the melancholy found within the film are none other but those of our reality, which is as aimless, incoherent and fragmented.

The details of the plot and the crime are left deliberately vague as to stress other aspects within the movie such as the intimate and poetic existential dialogues. Action is overshadowed by thought in order to demonstrate perhaps that what matters is not so much what happens, but rather how we perceive them, that there are no facts, only interpretations of them. Simple images can have tremendous meaning if one cares to attribute one to them. For instance, the scene featuring an apple trickling down the rocks into a flowing river and rolling further down the stream, is a deeply haunting one, almost spine-chilling in its impending symbolism. The apple falls from the tree to be found among piles of others, already rotten. It too, is bound to succumb to the natural process that inevitably follows and resolves only in decay. It is a process into disintegration, a reminder that life is the procession towards death and everything amounts to nothingness. A short, yet beautiful sequence, as this, can easily be interpreted as a parable of the futility of existence.

Screen-shot-2012-07-25-at-5.15.08-PMPerhaps, the process of the apple could even be simulated to the progress of the doctor himself, as by the end of the movie he succumbs to futility and sees no meaning in reporting that there was soil in the dead man’s lungs, denoting that he was buried alive. Through taking part in the morbid, yet deeply existential quest, he seems to have become prone to corruption, which manifests, in this manner, at the very end of the movie. He is but another fresh apple that is soon to join the pile of the rotten ones and eventually rot itself. He understands and claims his own place within the dark world of men and is thus destined to “rot” himself, infected by the decay of his surroundings. We cannot possibly know his actual motive for concealing the true nature of the murder, but it is obvious that he had a reason for it. We can only guess at it, as it remains opaque in the abrupt conclusion of the film. Life after all, has many interpretations and it is up to us to decide which conclusion to resort to and decide when and how the story ends, as it can continue in the endlessly generated assumptions of our minds. The movie simply ends without conclusion or warning, just like life itself.

During one of the pauses in which the others engage in the search of a body, a police officer stays behind, along with the doctor and the two engage in a one-dimensional conversation on necessity of murder when another’s survival is at stake. The officer presents himself as unhesitant and remorseless, when it comes to killing criminals and seems to view it as similar putting down a bad animal. He soon breaks off into a long monologue, while the camera focuses on the back of his head, giving us the impression that he articulates his thoughts outloud. Eventually, as the camera moves to a shot of his face, we notice his unmoving mouth and realize that whatever is said is only expressed within his own mind, illuminating thus, the complex internal dialogues that run in the background of events, contrasted with the superficial ideas people manage to articulate outloud and communicate efficiently to others. Questions are also raised, as to the nature of humanity and the contradictions embodied within it, such as an intriguing capacity for both ruthlessness and mercy.

The turning point in the movie seems to come from the appearance of the mayor’s daughter, which acts as a transition of sort. She is presented as almost a virginal figure that emanates a rare form of innocence, reflected in her facial expression and child-like beauty. Possibly due to the electric cut-out, she has a peculiar effect upon the men. As soon as she walks into the room, she illuminates the pitch-black night and chases the darkness away with the light she bears. She offers kindness in the form of coffee, which she offers to everyone indiscriminately. The criminal is clearly touched by the gesture and even weeps at her beautiful innocence that is juxtaposed with his own ruthlessness and murderous cruelty. The girl thus, elicits from him a strong emotional response that causes him to confess the exact location of the body. She is presented as comforting presence to the dark world of men, which however, seem disinterested in her internal world and compare her to a flower, an ornament of decorative value. Their approach possibly reflects the way women are generally seen in rural Turkey.

Overall, the film is an encounter with the nothingness of our existence, an encounter with questions that are never to be answered with more than with sheer assumptions, as reflected by the ending. One may call the nothing something, in an attempt to pacify one’s self. Similarly, the audiences can build theories, in an attempt to attribute a coherent meaning to the film as a whole, in a theoretical space, where there is no certainty, nor right or wrong, merely projections. The lack of a definite meaning, both in the film and in living, opens up a space of possibility for any individual to attribute one’s own interpretation of it and construct the meaning one chooses to see. Even so, there is no comfort to be found anywhere, no access to a clear-cut, objective reality, only a confinement within the subjectivity of our fragmented perceptions. An overwhelming futility creeps upon us, as we roam the dark, endless night of Anatolia alongside the characters, reflecting life itself, as none but our journey into disintegration.

once-upon-a-time-in-anatolia

The Skin I Live In (2011) By Pedro Almodóvar

MV5BMjMwOTYyNDY4NV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNDI1ODk0Ng@@._V1_SX640_SY720_The predominant theme of the film, is the forced transformation of a male to female, which is imposed and occurs as a corrective act. Vincent becomes Vera against his consent, as a punishment for allegedly raping Dr Robert Ledgard’s daughter. It seems that the desperate father chose the particular method as a punishment, in order for Vincent to gain the lived experience of a woman and therefore understand what it feels like to be one that is raped, as presumably his daughter was, in order to empathize with her and understand the damage he had caused her. The surgeon uses Vincent as test-subject for his artificial skin experiments and over a period of six years gradually turns him into a living memorial of his late wife Gal, with which, he as a she, comes to share a striking resemblance. Dr Ledgard gradually comes to develop a sort of attachment to Vera, most probably due to the familiarity of her face, combined with the overall loneliness that characterizes the mansion in which they live in. It serves as a prison for the both, as the nature of the surgeon’s experiments, along with Vincent’s fate, must remain secret. Vera is a prisoner, constantly surveyed by cameras and is subject to a panoptical method of discipline, while Robert is trapped in a cloistered world of his own device. Their mutual isolation, in combination to the sympathy Dr Ledgard might have felt for Vera after having been raped by Zeca, might have led to their coming together.

Even so, it is impossible not to be struck by the absurdity of a straight man being sexually attracted to the man who allegedly raped his daughter, solely because he came to occupy the form of a woman. As we find out, from his biological mother’s statements, Robert had, throughout his lifetime, frequently adopted a distinct stance to women, viewing them as very similar to children, that is, inherently innocent and vulnerable. This notion of womanhood has caused him to adopt an overly-trusting relationship with them, one that has often led him into trouble. One such example, which we find out of, is his wife Gal, who had run away with Zeca and got involved in a serious car accident that left her with horrific wounds. He attempted to heal her, in any way possible, just so he could have his wife back, despite her betrayal that possibly denoted her strong desire to leave him, showing thus a disregard for her actual wishes. He seems to forgive her as easily as you would forgive a child, as he perhaps deems her too, incapable of taking full responsibility for her actions and throws all the blame on Zeca instead. Gradually, it seems that Robert starts to perceive Vera as equally child-like and attributes to her traditional feminine characteristics that he presumes she has gained, along with her new body.

Robert did not only take away Vincent’s identity and life, but he also deprived him of his own skin, to replace it with a new one, immune to pain, but possibly to pleasure as well. However, it is clear that Vera still identifies with Vincent, despite actively pretending otherwise. When in private, she kisses the picture of her former self that has been stolen away and then proceeds to avenge the violence that was done to her. After all, in the very end she says “I’m Vincent” and not Vera, illustrating how gender identification is not skin-deep. Vincent had the lived experience of a man and was thus, unable to forcefully adjust to being a woman, although he learned to play the part of one, in order to carry out his plan. Having this in mind, it is possible to suggest that the brief affair among Vera and Robert was in fact homoerotic in nature. Robert makes the mistake to believe that Vincent is wiped away along with his male body, something that Vera actually takes advantage of and cultivates the notion even further, as to use it towards her own advantage later.

It is possible that the doctor reduced Vera into a mere body-object that simulated his wife, or it could be that he even perceived his wife as an embodiment of traditional femininity in the first place. Zeca commits the same mistake of judging solely by the flesh, taking Vera for Gal and even when evidence shows otherwise he appears to be utterly indifferent and rapes her anyway, treating her as an object that is to be used for his pleasure. It seems that neither Robert, nor Zeca, care for much else than Vera’s skin and the two, despite being presented as different, the one cultivated and the other vulgar, are brothers and essentially facets of the same coin of patriarchal oppression, in the sense that they perceive gender as a naturalized behaviour, rather than an internalized social construct. The whole thing however, proves to be a huge farce, as the joke is actually on them, given that Vera, the woman they attempt to take possession of, actually feels like a man.

16

Talk to Her (2002) by Pedro Almodóvar

talk-to-her-almodovar-19755

Through the relations between Alicia and Benigno, Almodóvar’s Talk to Her, possibly presents us with a parody of a typical heterosexual relationship within which the woman is objectified. The story usually goes something like, man meets woman, whom he finds extremely attractive and suddenly his life’s task becomes winning her affections. The film introduces us to Benigno, a presumably sensitive type of man who stalks a woman named Alicia. She appears almost as an embodiment of traditional femininity and beauty. Upon seeing her, Benigno is charmed by these qualities and starts to accumulate all of her interests as his own and seems prepared to go to any lengths to prove his alleged love for her. It is a recurring method of courtship that we frequently encounter in many cultural representations that celebrate it. Ultimately, the parody with which we are presented with, serves as to kick, the aforementioned stereotypes, up a notch and in this manner, expose them for what they truly are. We witness a twisted representation of love that illuminates the sinister implications that lie behind the façade of romance. It is essentially a dream turned nightmare.

Furthermore, Benigno solely obsesses over Alicia because he is charmed by her face and body, as he watches her dance from across the street to his apartment. He adopts her interests, only with the prospect of physical access to her. Taking these factors into consideration, it could be said that her comatose condition, that allows her to be biologically alive, but mentally dead, came out as very convenient to him. Benigno even expresses the desire to marry her, asserting that they are getting along better than most couples, given her irresponsive condition and that their union would be ideal. Since Alicia can’t object to anything, she is a mere body-object for him to use. Through a silent black and white movie, depicting a tiny man entering a plastic, clitoris-less vagina of a sleeping woman, we realize that Benigno has had unconsensual sexual intercourse with Alicia. The fake, unrealistic, parody of a vagina, serves as to suggest the missing link in Benigno and Alicia’s sexual encounter, which is her consent and pleasure. In the same note, the lack of a clitoris and the representation of the vagina within the movie, solely as a hole, in which the men are to insert themselves, precisely talks of the naturalized objectification and indifference towards women that frequently occurs in heteronormative structures. Overall, it seems that Benigno in his innocence, has internalized the dominant ideologies that promote this kind of a relationship dynamic, causing him to actively seek for a partner with which he could feel fulfilled in the sense of conforming to social standards. It seems that his social context has imposed limitations on his expressions of desire.

In addition, his private life may have contributed into his distorted perception of a perfect relationship. Through his encounter with Alicia’s father, who’s a psychologist, we hear of the unhealthy relationship Benigno has had with his mother and he even admits to miss her to a point of loneliness. He talks of the intensive and meticulous care he took of htalk_to_herer and his confessions allude to a possible oedipal complex. His mother is presented as an almost willless creature, characterized by total dependence on him, as he states that he took care of her for fifteen years and only went out for classes. His choice to be a nurse was very likely influenced from her utter reliance on him, as he even came to take classes of aesthetics, hairdressing and make-up, which he applied to her. He “cut her hair, dyed it, did her nails” and “scrubbed her down well front and back”, just as he also did for Alicia. His relationship with his mother comes out as too intimate to a point of being considered a taboo, causing the psychologist to remark that his adolescence was very special and that he would like to see him again in order to discuss it. His mum, as Benigno states wasn’t disabled or mad, just a bit lazy when it came to taking care of herself and taking into account that she was a beautiful woman, he kept taking care of her appearance as to not lose her looks. As we find out, his father, having left his mother and not maintaining any communication since, was not around in order to prevent the unnatural bond from springing. We are also informed that Benigno is a virgin, suggesting perhaps that his severed connection with his father, in combination with the co-dependence he has developed with his mother, prevented him from developing a fully-fledged sexual life.

Moreover, this idea is strongly supported by classical Freudian psychoanalytic theory, which claims that a child’s identification with the same-sex parent needs to be achieved in order for the Oedipus complex to subside and for the development of a mature sexual role and identity to occur. It is suggested that its unsuccessful resolution might lead to neurosis, paedophilia and homosexuality and that due to the male child’s recurring obsession with the mother-figure, it is very likely that in adult life he will make a choice of a sexual partner who resembles his parent. It seems that Benigno, through his experience with his mother, had learned to associate femininity with dependence and attempted to replace his mother with Alicia, for whom he performed the same intimate form of care and aesthetic treatments. His obsessive attachment to her strongly resembles the one described for his mother. He reluctantly retires from Alicia’s care to go out and in the few instances that he actually does, he pursues her own interests and thus attends dance performances and watches silent movies. Once again, Benigno prevents himself from building a life of his own, outside the vicious circle of co-dependence, which he has learned to seek and even idealize.

It almost appears as if Benigno lives in a dollhouse with his sole company being himself projected onto body-objects, while he remains oblivious of the outside world and is indifferent of real life and relationships. His life begins to change as he encounters Marco, a new presence in the hospital he works, whose girlfriend is in a comatose state too. Marco is in a vulnerable situation which prompts him to seek some understanding company. He finds it in Benigno, whom he perceives to be in a situation similar to his. The two men gradually develop a strong bond of friendship that is arguably the only real relationship presented on-screen. Throughout the whole movie there is an underlying homoerotic element which however remains concealed and can only be subtly read by those that care to look for it. It is almost as if Almodóvar taunts us with hints that point into an underlying romance between the two men. One such hint can be possibly found in the aforementioned Freudian theory, which claims that Benigno’s alienation from his father in combination with his failure to rid himself of Oedipus complex, could lead to potential homosexuality. Also, Benigno himself initially states that he sexually prefers men, while talking to Alicia’s father in the hospital. Even though it seems that his purpose was to reassure her father of his good intentions, the particular statement served, none the less, as a clue, as to where the audiences should direct their attention.

Right in the beginning of the film, we are shown a shot of the two men sitting right next to each other in the theatre, in a manner just as if they were a couple, clarifying thus, how the story is actually about them. Marco clearly intrigues Benigno right from the very beginning, as upon his return to Alicia he proceeds to describe to her, in meticulous detail, how touched the strange man was and how he wept at the sight of the performance. Then we are presented with Marco’s story and how in a funny twist of fate, Benigno was to meet him. It is almost as if the women were none but a complementary presence in the bigger scheme of things that was the meeting of the two men. It is an approach that can be said to parody cultural representations of romance and the notion of fate and coincidence playing a part in it. It is very possible that Benigno actually desired Marco, but directed his desire towards Alicia instead, due to the social norms at play. Upon deciding to commit suicide Benigno leaves all his possessions to Marco along with a heartfelt letter that acts almost as a confession of love aching to be put into words, the ultimate expression of the culturally unrepresentable desire.

talktoher

Lovers of the Arctic Circle (1998) by Julio Medem

Lovers_Of_The_Arctic_CircleIt is noteworthy, that both Otto and Anna’s names are palindromes, suggesting perhaps that the movie itself is a palindrome and as the title conveys, moves in circular patterns. All aspects within the plot seem to be connected and it is almost as if we get a glimpse into a universe that conspires towards the lover’s union. The overall themes and atmosphere are strongly reminiscent of Kieslowski’s films. Throughout the movie there is the omnipresent theme of death which is constantly countered by a love so strong that it seems to be able to surpass it. The events are always presented in two variations that allow for this very defiance of death. It is as if Anna and Otto’s sum of visions allow for the possibility of death to subside, with the second variation of an event almost acting as a second chance for their love to blossom. However, it seems that at the very end reality trickles in, as we see from Otto’s point of view, how Anna is hit by a bus and dies in arms. Unable to accept the facts of life, Anna’s love once again distorts her vision of reality and allows her to be with Otto.

The devote lover’s perception can be said to be very similar to that of a deeply-religious individual. Advocates and believers of the monotheistic dogma, meticulously examine their actions and ideas, as to make sure that their god is pleased with them. They come to assume a world-view in which everything revolves around their god’s presence and love. Their main concerns seem to lie in reaching as close to god as possible and win his merit. Through devoting to this relationship they hope to gain a sense of purpose and meaning in their lives that will alleviate them from existential struggle. God thus, acts as a moving force throughout their lives and sets the very foundations in their ideology, the instruments with which they shape their understanding and reach conclusions in regards to the world around them. Arguably, a lover acts and perceives in the very same way, aching for a divine connection with his significant other. It almost seems like a lover’s reality is separate from the rest of humanity, frequently characterised by magical elements 4933920770_582128e373_zsimilar to those found in the lives of firmly religious people, if one takes into consideration that there is no objective reality, only perceptions. After all, “God is love” and the world’s most powerful massive delusion.

Furthermore, nobody really knows god, people merely project their preconceptions and assumptions of what god is and yet they trust him with their lives, similar to the way lovers trust one another and build whole lives together despite the impossibility of ever fully knowing another. In a sense, all love is self-love, given that humans are confined into the limits of their own perception and the cognitive tools they have used to understand and build themselves. The lover inevitably projects aspects of the self onto the other and in the attempt to understand, eventually constructs the object of his love, which functions as a mere vessel. Thus, the lovers can be said to be indeed one, similar to the way a person is one with the god he imagined.

It seems, as illustrated by the film’s atmosphere of magical realism that what matters the most in Lovers of the Arctic Circle, is how one interprets events rather than the events themselves. Medem informs us during in an interview that “the movie is marked by coincidence and by an instinct of escapism from the reality the characters do not like…[since what] they are looking for is the utopia of love”, a concept much based on faith, which both advocates of love and religion heavily rely upon. Consequently, we are presented with a film outside the boundaries of reason, just like religion and love are. It is an ode to divine romance, a celebrated cultural production that reinforces and reproduces the establishment of dominant ideologies that regulate human relationships. It is a representation of a lifetime task that many advocates of the religion of love take upon, of reaching a union with the object of one’s affection. This very goal is embedded in the dual structure of the film itself that presents us with both Otto and Anna’s perspectives of the events. In essence, the two cinematic lovers are two parts of the same whole, which is the film itself.8_lovers-of-the-arctic-circle

Fight Club (1999) by David Fincher

fight-club-brad-pitt

Through the immerse success of the film Fight Club, the book was discovered and acquired a vast reading audience of exited movie fans. The popularity however, that the movie itself received, seems to subvert the book’s central anti-consumerist, anti-capitalist message, proving itself counterproductive in function, giving an anti-culture novel a mainstream status. As a result, the majority of the audience failed to see “Tyler’s” faults, both in ideology and on a more personal level. They too, seem to have idealized him in the same way the narrator and the rest of the fight club members did.fight_club_0441

The narrator is initially presented as a man clearly influenced by the media and the stereotypes of living they promote. Falling into the trap of ceaseless consumerism, he buys IKEA furniture in order to find the aesthetic qualities that will enable him to define himself. He seeks identity in what he buys, exhibiting how “the things you own end up owning you”. The narrator dreams of success and being part of the same mass culture that predestines him to unfulfillment. This desire unwittingly manifests as his alternate persona, the rebellious Tyler Durden, who in contrast to the ideology he conveys and the mask of liberation he wears, he paradoxically embodies all of society’s stereotypes of ideal masculinity, such as good looks, cocky attitude and overall aggression. He is presented as the classic alpha-male archetype, which the narrator could never hope to achieve. His urge to save humanity from its cultural constrains seems to be a false front for the urge to rule, to have the power and control the narrator always lacked. Through Tyler, the narrator seeks to form his own identity, by rebelling and becoming all that he was not. Tyler is thus, an inverted image of himself, a manifestation of undisclosed desires.Img1

In order to demonstrate this dynamic within the movie, Edward Norton, who embodies the narrator, has during the course of the filming, starved himself, while Brad Pitt lifted weights and went on tanning beds. The goal was to highlight Tyler’s physical superiority over the narrator, as he had to be idealized. This portrayal came out as very successful in the movie and the casting choices proved wise. A mainstream icon like Brad Pitt, was chosen to carry out a role of an anti-mainstream character, whose actions subvert the very ideology he preaches, freedom, deeming him no better than a mainstream fascist. With his charm, Tyler lured people into his Nazi-like cult, used their disappointment at mass culture to fuel his fascist “revolution”. Fight club, in essence, embodies all the values which it condemns. It is frequently used as a means to convey anti-capitalistic messages, but it includes every aspect of supposed faults of capitalism, such as the survival of the fittest, competitiveness and desires of domination. Fight club’s message eventually subverts itself and it seems that capitalism, subsumes even the cultural products that attempt to subvert it, with people ironically building fortunes out of anti-consumerism.

A very radical difference imagesbetween film and book, which bespeaks of how a translation to the big screen can never be fully faithful to the original, is the ending. It is illustrative of how it is often the case that the translations serve a completely different function. Each medium’s ending conveys a different message. The book’s ending is arguably darker than the one of the movie. The protagonist is arrested and finds himself stuck in a psychiatric ward, completely disoriented and powerless. He is then approached by various workers in the ward who inform him: “Don’t worry Mr. Tyler we’ll get you out”. This incident has a spine chilling effect, as the reader realizes that fight club has expanded far more than originally intended and its people have infiltrated everywhere. It serves as to show that ideas once created cannot be destroyed and accumulate a life of their own, independent of the person that created them. The narrator has set a “fire” in motion, through Tyler, a fire that he can no longer control and he himself was consumed by it. The movie, on the other hand, seems to present us of a coming of age story with a fulfilling ending. We witness the narrator shifting from a consumerist fightclubpicidentity to a violent revolutionary one, from one pole to another in his attempt to define himself. He attains an identity of his own, only when he realizes the sinister implications in both lifestyles and comes to overcome his “mentor”, as he is overcome by the need to become his own person.

Film Criticism

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free